Today, just over one year after a four-week trial, which ended with a hung jury, United States District Judge Jessica Clarke ordered a judgment of acquittal and dismissed all charges against Fick & Marx client, Anton Peraire-Bueno, and his brother, James Peraire-Bueno. The brothers had been accused of committing wire fraud and other crimes in connection with multimillion-dollar trades on the Ethereum cryptocurrency network. Based on the all the evidence, Judge Clark concluded that Anton and James never lied to anyone about their trading activity and thus committed no crime.
Responding to the decision, Anton Peraire-Bueno said, “We are overjoyed at this wonderful news. Our family and friends rearranged their lives around this case for two-and-a-half years so that we might see a day like today. We owe a debt of gratitude to the lawyers, the amici, and the countless people and organizations that stood up for us when it mattered most.”
“When it announced the charges against Anton and James, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in the S.D.N.Y. called this prosecution the ‘first of its kind,’” added attorney William Fick. “But as the Court’s decision makes clear, the case never should have been brought in the first place.”
“From the start, this flawed prosecution was based on fundamental misunderstandings about decentralized financial networks, like Ethereum, and put the U.S. government on the side of sophisticated international actors who engage in automated ‘sandwich’ trading at the expense of retail crypto investors,” Marx explained.
“Smart, creative entrepreneurs, like the Peraire-Buenos, should be celebrated, not prosecuted, especially if the U.S. hopes to be the crypto capital of the world,” said Fick.
“Defending the Peraire-Buenos, alongside Williams & Connolly LLP, where I previously practiced, was an incredible experience,” added Marx. “Every member of their trial team was an effective, relentless, and fearless advocate, and we are grateful for everyone’s extraordinary contributions to this outstanding result.”
Reuters, Bloomberg, and Law360 all featured stories on the acquittal.
Fick: “Federal prosecutors should think twice before trying to regulate rapidly evolving technologies with novel ‘fraud’ indictments.”
